Results and Rankings

Results for methods appear here after users upload them and approve them for public display.



EPE all EPE matched EPE unmatched d0-10 d10-60 d60-140 s0-10 s10-40 s40+
GroundTruth [1] 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 Visualize Results
RAFT [2] 1.609 0.623 9.647 1.621 0.518 0.301 0.341 1.036 9.288 Visualize Results
Deformable_RAFT [3] 1.667 0.627 10.151 1.631 0.519 0.277 0.338 0.993 9.897 Visualize Results
RAFT-TF_RVC [4] 1.837 0.776 10.499 2.125 0.652 0.321 0.352 1.193 10.767 Visualize Results
DICL+ [5] 1.863 0.741 11.014 2.222 0.519 0.330 0.380 1.167 10.905 Visualize Results
ADLAB-PRFlow [6] 1.885 0.633 12.104 1.599 0.472 0.307 0.406 1.009 11.350 Visualize Results
C-RAFT_RVC [7] 2.287 0.983 12.924 1.930 0.753 0.592 0.351 1.196 14.535 Visualize Results
RAFT+LCV [8] 2.489 1.002 14.630 2.793 0.686 0.470 0.525 1.448 14.769 Visualize Results
MR-Flow [9] 2.527 0.954 15.365 2.866 0.710 0.420 0.446 1.715 14.826 Visualize Results
ADW [10] 2.504 1.158 13.487 2.822 0.987 0.549 0.412 1.457 15.425 Visualize Results
MaskFlownet [11] 2.521 0.989 15.032 2.742 0.908 0.291 0.361 1.285 16.261 Visualize Results
GCA-Net-ft+ [12] 2.695 0.980 16.699 2.671 0.837 0.392 0.581 1.423 16.283 Visualize Results
VCN [13] 2.808 1.108 16.682 3.267 0.867 0.418 0.646 1.669 16.302 Visualize Results
H-v3 [14] 2.452 0.622 17.409 1.433 0.545 0.389 0.284 1.127 16.444 Visualize Results
ProFlow_ROB [15] 2.709 1.013 16.549 2.843 0.723 0.518 0.485 1.586 16.470 Visualize Results
vcn+MSDRNet [16] 2.595 0.889 16.528 2.632 0.694 0.350 0.435 1.279 16.526 Visualize Results
MRFP [17] 2.652 1.021 15.964 2.597 0.618 0.505 0.439 1.369 16.749 Visualize Results
VCN+LCV [18] 2.833 1.093 17.039 3.210 0.875 0.400 0.607 1.607 16.860 Visualize Results
metaFlow [19] 2.710 1.089 15.931 2.738 0.706 0.602 0.465 1.456 16.890 Visualize Results
DICL-Flow [20] 2.634 0.967 16.237 2.494 0.621 0.492 0.388 1.349 16.895 Visualize Results
StarFlow [21] 2.718 1.111 15.839 2.738 0.891 0.521 0.512 1.372 16.939 Visualize Results
PRAFlow_RVC [22] 2.475 1.011 14.423 1.658 0.775 0.745 0.248 0.979 17.169 Visualize Results
ProFlow [23] 2.818 1.027 17.428 2.892 0.751 0.496 0.469 1.626 17.369 Visualize Results
FlowFields++ [24] 2.943 0.850 20.027 2.550 0.603 0.403 0.560 1.859 17.401 Visualize Results
SfM-PM [25] 2.910 1.016 18.357 2.797 0.756 0.479 0.559 1.732 17.431 Visualize Results
VCN_RVC [26] 2.827 1.134 16.645 2.864 0.922 0.524 0.506 1.480 17.614 Visualize Results
GCA-Net [27] 2.947 1.032 18.585 2.900 0.830 0.456 0.602 1.645 17.753 Visualize Results
MaskFlownet-S [28] 2.771 1.077 16.608 2.901 0.996 0.342 0.419 1.404 17.777 Visualize Results
PST [29] 3.110 0.942 20.809 2.759 0.664 0.378 0.635 2.069 17.919 Visualize Results
MPIF [30] 3.111 1.134 19.218 3.070 0.939 0.523 0.616 1.980 18.220 Visualize Results
LiteFlowNet3 [31] 2.994 1.148 18.077 3.000 0.985 0.498 0.559 1.670 18.302 Visualize Results
FlowFields+ [32] 3.102 0.820 21.718 2.340 0.616 0.373 0.593 1.865 18.549 Visualize Results
LiteFlowNet3-S [33] 3.028 1.173 18.182 3.079 0.996 0.527 0.574 1.646 18.566 Visualize Results
DIP-Flow [34] 3.103 0.881 21.227 2.574 0.681 0.419 0.548 1.801 18.979 Visualize Results
CoT-AMFlow [35] 3.141 1.247 18.623 3.226 1.067 0.517 0.590 1.816 19.032 Visualize Results
LSM_FLOW_RVC [36] 2.998 1.216 17.539 2.848 0.964 0.649 0.503 1.477 19.072 Visualize Results
L0-norm-Flow2 [37] 3.298 1.069 21.502 2.512 0.826 0.600 0.711 1.940 19.449 Visualize Results
PGM-C [38] 3.234 0.929 22.045 2.724 0.659 0.424 0.567 1.999 19.467 Visualize Results
CPM2 [39] 3.253 0.980 21.812 2.663 0.751 0.416 0.615 1.954 19.503 Visualize Results
SegPM+Interpolation [40] 3.513 1.269 21.839 2.894 1.012 0.727 0.910 2.164 19.723 Visualize Results
TV-Wavelet-Flow [41] 3.355 1.104 21.744 2.684 0.861 0.570 0.682 2.061 19.777 Visualize Results
PWC-Net+ [42] 3.454 1.413 20.116 3.917 1.247 0.490 0.751 2.230 19.846 Visualize Results
SegFlow33 [43] 3.356 1.033 22.322 2.592 0.769 0.524 0.686 1.937 20.062 Visualize Results
MFF [44] 3.423 1.381 20.099 3.783 1.233 0.486 0.698 2.144 20.062 Visualize Results
L0-normFlow [45] 3.327 1.015 22.217 2.405 0.781 0.554 0.665 1.879 20.071 Visualize Results
FrequencyFlow [46] 3.359 1.046 22.262 2.529 0.812 0.547 0.667 1.966 20.118 Visualize Results
SJTU_PAMI418 [47] 3.576 1.542 20.193 4.123 1.409 0.555 0.851 2.328 20.156 Visualize Results
DiscreteFlow+OIR [48] 3.331 0.942 22.817 2.794 0.712 0.442 0.583 1.948 20.318 Visualize Results
ARFlow-mv-ft [49] 3.197 1.358 18.216 3.446 1.240 0.500 0.499 1.624 20.410 Visualize Results
HMFlow [50] 3.206 1.122 20.210 2.786 0.957 0.584 0.467 1.693 20.470 Visualize Results
MirrorFlow [51] 3.316 1.338 19.470 3.684 1.165 0.487 0.566 1.853 20.523 Visualize Results
FullFlow [52] 3.601 1.296 22.424 2.944 1.023 0.732 0.933 2.055 20.612 Visualize Results
FlowSAC_ff [53] 3.346 0.972 22.712 2.666 0.822 0.444 0.524 1.986 20.648 Visualize Results
STC-Flow [54] 3.515 1.443 20.438 3.750 1.340 0.539 0.674 2.257 20.680 Visualize Results
ContinualFlow_ROB [55] 3.341 1.752 16.292 4.057 1.656 0.792 0.512 1.941 20.755 Visualize Results
DiscreteFlow [56] 3.567 1.108 23.626 3.398 0.799 0.446 0.703 2.277 20.906 Visualize Results
FullFlow+KF [57] 3.598 1.247 22.779 2.957 0.977 0.677 0.844 1.974 21.212 Visualize Results
DCFlow [58] 3.537 1.103 23.394 2.897 0.868 0.632 0.703 2.015 21.296 Visualize Results
RicFlow [59] 3.550 1.264 22.220 3.248 1.023 0.576 0.601 2.203 21.465 Visualize Results
SegFlow73 [60] 3.463 1.008 23.497 2.682 0.781 0.522 0.563 1.977 21.466 Visualize Results
FlowSAC_dcf [61] 3.600 1.161 23.506 2.972 0.930 0.712 0.716 2.121 21.502 Visualize Results
FDFlowNet [62] 3.707 1.543 21.376 3.814 1.421 0.690 0.837 2.198 21.630 Visualize Results
AugFNG_ROB [63] 3.606 1.603 19.939 3.637 1.376 0.868 0.666 2.142 21.736 Visualize Results
OAS-Net [64] 3.653 1.490 21.322 3.809 1.393 0.587 0.749 2.129 21.783 Visualize Results
CPM-Flow [65] 3.557 1.189 22.889 3.032 0.973 0.613 0.592 2.064 21.900 Visualize Results
S2F-IF [66] 3.500 0.988 23.986 2.629 0.816 0.533 0.524 1.976 21.960 Visualize Results
LiteFlowNet2 [67] 3.483 1.383 20.637 3.293 1.263 0.629 0.597 1.772 21.976 Visualize Results
CPM_AUG [68] 3.609 1.135 23.804 2.945 0.935 0.516 0.615 2.099 22.137 Visualize Results
SegFlow-CNN [69] 3.463 1.130 22.521 3.084 0.936 0.523 0.467 1.892 22.160 Visualize Results
DCFlow+KF [70] 3.585 1.142 23.502 3.036 0.921 0.630 0.597 2.017 22.208 Visualize Results
CompactFlow [71] 3.455 1.294 21.100 3.327 1.180 0.498 0.547 1.658 22.261 Visualize Results
RichFlow-ft [72] 3.541 1.335 21.553 3.527 1.201 0.538 0.566 1.857 22.404 Visualize Results
ProbFlowFields [73] 3.631 1.061 24.603 2.719 0.887 0.607 0.551 2.105 22.619 Visualize Results
DistillFlow+ft [74] 3.487 1.479 19.904 3.894 1.415 0.488 0.449 1.742 22.824 Visualize Results
SPM-BPv2 [75] 3.515 1.020 23.865 2.603 0.841 0.521 0.474 1.773 22.830 Visualize Results
DCFlow+KF2 [76] 3.645 1.149 23.992 3.037 0.932 0.640 0.586 1.974 22.867 Visualize Results
3Dflow [77] 3.520 1.086 23.385 3.039 0.879 0.485 0.440 1.841 22.879 Visualize Results
PatchBatch+Inter [78] 3.624 1.324 22.397 3.076 1.115 0.673 0.589 1.824 23.062 Visualize Results
UnDAF-MaskFlownet [79] 3.590 1.410 21.403 3.485 1.272 0.588 0.543 1.772 23.151 Visualize Results
IRR-PWC_RVC [80] 3.785 2.039 18.039 4.046 1.703 1.039 0.684 2.114 23.234 Visualize Results
ScopeFlow [81] 3.592 1.400 21.497 3.457 1.261 0.592 0.534 1.742 23.286 Visualize Results
CompactFlow-woscv [82] 3.596 1.374 21.734 3.399 1.314 0.539 0.551 1.672 23.388 Visualize Results
FastFlow [83] 3.997 1.832 21.653 4.469 1.719 0.833 0.779 2.538 23.496 Visualize Results
DeepDiscreteFlow [84] 3.863 1.296 24.820 3.077 0.975 0.803 0.794 2.024 23.575 Visualize Results
FlowFieldsCNN [85] 3.778 0.996 26.469 2.604 0.796 0.631 0.648 2.017 23.582 Visualize Results
SENSE [86] 3.599 1.375 21.752 3.102 1.144 0.720 0.527 1.640 23.598 Visualize Results
FlowFields [87] 3.748 1.056 25.700 2.784 0.878 0.570 0.546 2.110 23.602 Visualize Results
FastFlow2 [88] 4.128 1.887 22.415 4.323 1.765 0.919 0.894 2.609 23.855 Visualize Results
InterpoNet_df [89] 3.862 1.193 25.632 3.613 0.885 0.508 0.581 2.253 24.038 Visualize Results
Semantic_Lattice [90] 3.838 1.700 21.304 3.855 1.434 0.795 0.599 1.995 24.396 Visualize Results
FF++_ROB [91] 3.953 1.148 26.836 3.255 0.910 0.519 0.582 2.351 24.562 Visualize Results
InterpoNet_dm [92] 3.973 1.412 24.852 4.015 1.032 0.636 0.706 2.142 24.619 Visualize Results
PWC-Net+KF2 [93] 3.753 1.588 21.445 3.657 1.298 0.723 0.460 1.863 24.700 Visualize Results
PWC-Net_RVC [94] 3.897 1.726 21.637 3.950 1.425 0.812 0.618 2.033 24.705 Visualize Results
PPM [95] 4.026 1.167 27.353 2.783 0.847 0.690 0.797 2.093 24.748 Visualize Results
InterpoNet_ff [96] 3.952 1.232 26.121 3.600 0.946 0.573 0.571 2.228 24.900 Visualize Results
SBFlow [97] 3.930 1.285 25.541 3.352 1.093 0.614 0.569 2.161 24.922 Visualize Results
SegFlow113 [98] 3.869 1.132 26.210 2.855 0.942 0.667 0.550 1.945 25.018 Visualize Results
EPMNet [99] 3.986 1.502 24.251 3.230 1.349 0.908 0.695 1.981 25.181 Visualize Results
PWC-Net+KF [100] 3.850 1.595 22.276 3.664 1.302 0.734 0.459 1.957 25.289 Visualize Results
FlowNet2 [101] 3.959 1.468 24.294 3.089 1.319 0.920 0.643 1.898 25.422 Visualize Results
IRR-PWC [102] 3.844 1.472 23.220 3.509 1.296 0.721 0.535 1.724 25.430 Visualize Results
InterpoNet_cpm [103] 4.086 1.371 26.222 3.992 1.064 0.569 0.637 2.325 25.466 Visualize Results
OccInpFlow [104] 4.259 1.731 24.918 4.197 1.609 0.658 0.819 2.563 25.473 Visualize Results
FPCR-Net [105] 4.074 1.692 23.516 3.760 1.550 0.798 0.700 2.157 25.479 Visualize Results
FPCR-Net2 [106] 4.074 1.692 23.519 3.761 1.550 0.798 0.699 2.157 25.483 Visualize Results
FastFlowNet-ft+ [107] 4.193 1.648 24.992 4.196 1.483 0.696 0.798 2.368 25.490 Visualize Results
TIMCflow [108] 3.979 1.249 26.243 3.775 0.904 0.540 0.567 2.079 25.518 Visualize Results
DPCTF [109] 3.542 1.237 22.350 2.271 0.983 0.792 0.291 1.111 25.580 Visualize Results
SelFlow [110] 3.745 1.449 22.502 3.616 1.374 0.592 0.397 1.570 25.664 Visualize Results
FlowNetC-MD [111] 4.411 2.196 22.472 4.188 2.040 1.173 1.057 2.475 25.727 Visualize Results
EpicFlow [112] 4.115 1.360 26.595 3.660 1.079 0.599 0.712 2.117 25.859 Visualize Results
DistillFlow [113] 4.230 1.548 26.131 3.965 1.541 0.491 0.720 2.502 25.865 Visualize Results
Lavon [114] 4.120 1.603 24.631 3.162 1.359 1.038 0.736 2.029 25.968 Visualize Results
GlobalPatchCollider [115] 4.134 1.432 26.179 3.914 1.268 0.554 0.613 2.232 26.222 Visualize Results
DefFlowP [116] 4.334 2.131 22.272 4.271 1.910 1.206 0.710 2.679 26.284 Visualize Results
ERFlow [117] 4.393 2.002 23.912 4.481 2.041 0.875 0.937 2.423 26.331 Visualize Results
IOFPL-CVr8-ft [118] 3.757 1.337 23.522 2.803 1.141 0.765 0.398 1.288 26.430 Visualize Results
PRichFlow [119] 3.967 1.545 23.751 3.865 1.518 0.558 0.512 1.758 26.496 Visualize Results
Devon [120] 4.343 1.742 25.577 4.115 1.531 0.816 0.763 2.449 26.716 Visualize Results
Flownet2-IAER [121] 4.061 1.483 25.115 3.324 1.377 0.808 0.575 1.814 26.829 Visualize Results
Flownet2-IA [122] 4.114 1.520 25.304 3.530 1.377 0.809 0.606 1.877 26.968 Visualize Results
OF-OEF [123] 4.159 1.716 24.119 3.813 1.541 0.771 0.581 1.948 27.304 Visualize Results
FlowNet2-ft-sintel [124] 4.157 1.557 25.403 3.272 1.461 0.856 0.597 1.890 27.347 Visualize Results
PCF-F [125] 3.838 1.447 23.362 2.375 1.030 1.115 0.372 1.186 27.480 Visualize Results
SegFlow153 [126] 4.151 1.246 27.855 3.072 1.143 0.656 0.486 2.000 27.563 Visualize Results
PH-Flow [127] 4.388 1.714 26.202 3.612 1.713 0.834 0.590 2.430 27.997 Visualize Results
IHBPFlow [128] 4.347 1.476 27.746 3.573 1.155 0.895 0.577 2.245 28.145 Visualize Results
HSVFlow [129] 4.778 1.962 27.739 3.470 1.617 1.423 1.120 2.462 28.554 Visualize Results
ARFlow-mv [130] 4.494 1.887 25.801 4.415 1.853 0.794 0.700 2.299 28.676 Visualize Results
PWC-Net [131] 4.386 1.719 26.166 4.282 1.657 0.674 0.606 2.070 28.793 Visualize Results
StruPyNet-ft [132] 4.401 1.573 27.503 3.613 1.449 0.747 0.630 2.021 28.915 Visualize Results
tfFlowNet2 [133] 4.486 1.684 27.364 3.694 1.477 1.064 0.681 2.078 29.232 Visualize Results
StruPyNet [134] 4.517 1.728 27.290 3.786 1.755 0.850 0.659 2.227 29.238 Visualize Results
RichFlow-ft-fnl [135] 4.315 1.609 26.416 3.943 1.574 0.644 0.515 1.774 29.363 Visualize Results
FALDOI [136] 4.927 1.542 32.535 3.307 1.318 0.885 1.047 2.647 29.719 Visualize Results
ARFlow [137] 4.782 1.908 28.261 4.413 1.865 0.768 0.807 2.576 29.893 Visualize Results
FGI [138] 4.664 1.540 30.110 3.771 1.336 0.850 0.669 2.310 30.185 Visualize Results
F2PD_JJN [139] 4.604 1.925 26.456 3.764 1.633 1.232 0.643 2.074 30.396 Visualize Results
ER-FLOW2 [140] 4.986 2.181 27.878 4.968 2.217 1.010 0.909 2.848 30.416 Visualize Results
FAOP-Flow [141] 5.065 1.349 35.368 3.548 1.044 0.694 1.028 2.726 30.774 Visualize Results
tfFlowNet2+GLR [142] 4.594 1.736 27.918 3.728 1.566 1.082 0.584 1.963 30.888 Visualize Results
AggregFlow [143] 4.754 1.694 29.685 3.705 1.603 0.981 0.650 2.251 31.184 Visualize Results
FastFlowNet [144] 4.886 1.789 30.182 4.252 1.638 0.912 0.814 2.363 31.242 Visualize Results
TF+OFM [145] 4.917 1.874 29.735 3.676 1.689 1.309 0.839 2.349 31.391 Visualize Results
LiteFlowNet [146] 4.539 1.630 28.291 3.274 1.438 0.928 0.500 1.733 31.412 Visualize Results
DeepFlow2 [147] 4.891 1.403 33.317 3.714 1.119 0.626 0.800 2.210 31.690 Visualize Results
IOFPL-ft [148] 4.394 1.611 27.128 3.059 1.421 0.943 0.391 1.292 31.812 Visualize Results
BOOM+PF.XY [149] 5.204 1.696 33.826 3.512 1.540 1.021 0.927 2.921 31.976 Visualize Results
Deep+R [150] 5.041 1.481 34.047 3.710 1.102 0.722 0.929 2.333 31.999 Visualize Results
BOOM+PF.XYT [151] 5.311 1.820 33.809 3.552 1.661 1.180 1.049 3.031 32.008 Visualize Results
F3-MPLF [152] 4.771 2.063 26.863 3.458 1.809 1.244 0.678 1.884 32.091 Visualize Results
SegFlow193 [153] 4.893 1.570 31.973 3.375 1.450 1.157 0.533 2.064 33.382 Visualize Results
SparseFlowFused [154] 5.257 1.627 34.834 4.211 1.397 0.729 0.880 2.567 33.489 Visualize Results
PPAC-HD3 [155] 4.589 1.507 29.751 2.788 1.340 1.068 0.355 1.289 33.624 Visualize Results
DeepFlow [156] 5.377 1.771 34.751 4.519 1.534 0.837 0.960 2.730 33.701 Visualize Results
HD3F+MSDRNet [157] 4.595 1.458 30.167 2.835 1.254 1.024 0.310 1.188 34.124 Visualize Results
SPM-BP [158] 5.202 1.815 32.839 4.008 1.704 1.179 0.643 2.576 34.214 Visualize Results
DDC_Net_stacked2 [159] 5.342 2.677 27.075 4.770 2.763 1.562 0.688 2.837 34.486 Visualize Results
HD3-Flow [160] 4.788 1.622 30.633 3.225 1.379 1.117 0.395 1.410 34.802 Visualize Results
DDC-Net [161] 5.342 2.666 27.171 4.643 2.761 1.588 0.656 2.750 34.864 Visualize Results
AnyFlow [162] 6.066 2.412 35.852 5.211 2.432 1.215 1.429 3.665 34.900 Visualize Results
PCA-Layers [163] 5.730 2.455 32.468 5.447 2.337 1.415 1.129 3.051 35.079 Visualize Results
DMF_ROB [164] 5.368 1.742 34.899 4.271 1.613 0.831 0.753 2.511 35.180 Visualize Results
AutoScaler+ [165] 6.076 2.569 34.656 4.610 2.195 1.863 1.298 3.737 35.431 Visualize Results
Deep-EIP [166] 5.434 2.023 33.258 3.793 1.837 1.614 0.952 2.147 35.657 Visualize Results
SVFilterOh [167] 5.540 2.043 34.067 3.875 1.865 1.625 0.778 2.713 36.033 Visualize Results
PMF [168] 5.378 1.858 34.102 3.877 1.835 1.235 0.628 2.428 36.128 Visualize Results
NNF-Local [169] 5.386 1.397 37.896 2.722 1.341 1.004 0.683 2.245 36.342 Visualize Results
UFlow [170] 5.205 2.036 31.058 4.000 1.921 1.199 0.507 1.969 36.382 Visualize Results
ResPWCR_ROB [171] 5.674 3.138 26.380 4.941 2.769 2.127 0.879 2.506 37.143 Visualize Results
PatchWMF-OF [172] 5.550 1.781 36.257 3.339 1.843 1.277 0.581 2.612 37.319 Visualize Results
Grts-Flow-V2 [173] 6.415 2.664 36.995 5.177 2.482 1.773 1.310 3.983 37.635 Visualize Results
RGBFlow [174] 6.133 3.060 31.156 4.835 2.727 2.125 1.257 2.888 38.165 Visualize Results
ICALD [175] 6.002 2.376 35.550 4.835 2.636 1.213 0.758 3.459 38.169 Visualize Results
ZZZ [176] 6.027 1.681 41.429 3.637 1.547 1.038 0.994 2.809 38.798 Visualize Results
WLIF-Flow [177] 5.734 1.759 38.125 3.242 1.818 1.296 0.597 2.512 39.036 Visualize Results
ComponentFusion [178] 6.065 2.033 38.912 4.114 2.063 1.213 0.910 2.996 39.074 Visualize Results
AGIF+OF [179] 5.766 1.695 38.936 3.034 1.709 1.329 0.613 2.554 39.121 Visualize Results
EPPM [180] 6.494 2.675 37.632 4.997 2.422 1.948 1.402 3.446 39.152 Visualize Results
M-1px [181] 6.209 1.783 42.262 3.807 1.625 1.093 1.078 3.081 39.236 Visualize Results
MDP-Flow2 [182] 5.837 1.869 38.158 3.210 1.913 1.441 0.640 2.603 39.459 Visualize Results
pwc_xx [183] 5.767 2.495 32.479 4.493 2.229 1.628 0.752 2.121 39.523 Visualize Results
RC-LSTM-4dir [184] 6.694 3.419 33.345 5.930 3.513 2.162 1.375 3.826 39.961 Visualize Results
LocalLayering [185] 5.820 2.143 35.784 3.817 2.342 1.399 0.580 2.461 39.976 Visualize Results
RC-LSTM-1dir [186] 6.717 3.445 33.352 5.916 3.527 2.209 1.410 3.820 40.001 Visualize Results
COF_2019 [187] 6.171 2.596 35.298 5.385 2.883 1.263 0.725 3.298 40.142 Visualize Results
HCOF+multi [188] 6.717 3.244 35.046 5.724 3.175 2.290 1.223 4.158 40.158 Visualize Results
UnsupSimFlow [189] 5.926 2.159 36.655 4.302 1.977 1.217 0.631 2.508 40.503 Visualize Results
FlowNetC+ft+v [190] 6.081 2.576 34.620 5.079 2.371 1.480 0.764 2.686 40.676 Visualize Results
FlowNetS+ft+v [191] 6.158 2.800 33.491 5.535 2.687 1.563 0.766 2.938 40.686 Visualize Results
DSPyNet [192] 6.552 3.105 34.690 5.497 3.351 1.857 1.225 3.365 40.738 Visualize Results
DSPyNet+ft [193] 6.224 2.743 34.602 5.102 2.937 1.562 0.881 2.842 40.954 Visualize Results
COF [194] 6.496 2.849 36.216 5.679 3.176 1.450 0.859 3.656 41.334 Visualize Results
DDFlow [195] 6.176 2.269 38.053 4.208 2.084 1.416 0.860 2.562 41.337 Visualize Results
OAR-Flow [196] 6.227 2.760 34.455 5.639 3.096 1.375 0.648 3.132 41.378 Visualize Results
ContFusion [197] 6.263 2.518 36.767 5.092 2.801 1.302 0.694 3.115 41.506 Visualize Results
PatchBatch-CENT+SD [198] 5.789 2.743 30.599 5.232 2.756 1.492 0.492 1.801 41.746 Visualize Results
PCA-Flow [199] 6.828 3.014 37.939 6.444 3.038 1.655 1.363 3.484 42.048 Visualize Results
SparseFlow [200] 6.197 2.357 37.460 4.642 2.273 1.392 0.681 2.533 42.422 Visualize Results
Pwc_ps [201] 6.199 2.631 35.330 4.653 2.370 1.718 0.808 2.241 42.582 Visualize Results
SPyNet [202] 6.689 3.020 36.596 5.770 3.289 1.562 0.911 3.455 43.207 Visualize Results
SPyNet+ft [203] 6.640 3.013 36.190 5.501 3.122 1.719 0.832 3.343 43.442 Visualize Results
SFL [204] 7.455 4.129 34.548 7.148 4.322 2.448 1.437 4.756 43.773 Visualize Results
SAnet [205] 6.953 3.682 33.584 5.694 3.714 2.432 1.018 3.487 44.750 Visualize Results
GeoFlow [206] 6.527 2.420 40.043 3.945 2.193 1.857 0.723 2.620 44.833 Visualize Results
Back2FutureFlow_UFO [207] 7.227 3.603 36.779 6.100 3.497 2.458 1.224 4.003 44.836 Visualize Results
WOLF_ROB [208] 6.947 3.238 37.153 5.828 3.405 1.835 0.976 3.454 45.036 Visualize Results
Classic+NLP [209] 6.731 2.949 37.545 5.573 3.291 1.648 0.638 3.296 45.290 Visualize Results
SelFlow [210] 6.555 2.665 38.298 4.816 2.532 1.661 0.766 2.277 45.691 Visualize Results
EgFlow-cl [211] 6.580 2.706 38.163 4.563 2.463 2.015 0.671 2.449 45.930 Visualize Results
FlowNetProbOut [212] 7.472 3.888 36.700 6.833 4.056 2.424 1.196 4.422 45.962 Visualize Results
FC-2Layers-FF [213] 6.781 3.053 37.144 5.841 3.390 1.688 0.580 3.308 45.962 Visualize Results
FlowNetADF [214] 7.464 3.915 36.404 6.853 4.094 2.377 1.171 4.412 46.057 Visualize Results
HAST [215] 6.802 3.081 37.112 4.641 3.111 2.245 0.683 3.022 46.330 Visualize Results
IPOL_Brox [216] 7.283 3.150 40.931 5.705 3.347 1.831 1.090 3.647 46.796 Visualize Results
FSU-Net [217] 6.617 2.888 37.059 4.710 2.777 1.971 0.677 2.008 47.305 Visualize Results
EPIflow [218] 7.003 2.907 40.443 5.098 2.712 1.809 0.882 2.789 47.616 Visualize Results
DF-Beta [219] 7.391 3.153 41.890 5.492 3.337 1.895 1.087 3.597 47.836 Visualize Results
CPNFlow [220] 7.660 3.853 38.695 6.804 4.130 2.223 1.347 3.952 47.942 Visualize Results
DF [221] 7.406 3.164 41.936 5.504 3.345 1.908 1.091 3.594 47.949 Visualize Results
CNet [222] 6.866 3.122 37.403 4.890 3.002 2.283 0.743 2.405 48.087 Visualize Results
Channel-Flow [223] 7.023 3.086 39.084 5.411 3.236 1.918 0.624 2.791 49.021 Visualize Results
JOF [224] 6.920 3.080 38.195 5.983 3.416 1.678 0.583 2.474 49.143 Visualize Results
OatNet01 [225] 8.533 5.090 36.559 7.084 5.251 3.809 1.932 5.233 49.168 Visualize Results
NLTGV-SC [226] 7.680 3.565 41.168 6.132 3.801 2.170 0.996 3.557 50.808 Visualize Results
Data-Flow [227] 7.972 3.494 44.527 6.341 3.665 1.921 1.258 3.970 51.049 Visualize Results
MLDP-OF [228] 7.297 3.260 40.183 5.581 3.304 2.007 0.600 2.916 51.146 Visualize Results
TV-L1+EM [229] 7.675 3.340 42.946 6.277 3.576 1.962 0.914 3.549 51.185 Visualize Results
LDOF [230] 7.563 3.432 41.170 5.353 3.284 2.454 0.936 2.908 51.696 Visualize Results
FlowNetC+OFR [231] 8.525 4.864 38.360 6.873 5.189 3.675 1.665 4.551 52.146 Visualize Results
DictFlowS [232] 8.139 4.297 39.446 6.630 4.470 2.977 1.222 4.096 52.219 Visualize Results
TVL1_ROB [233] 8.233 4.012 42.600 7.010 4.432 2.381 1.172 4.480 52.331 Visualize Results
TVL1_RVC [234] 8.233 4.012 42.600 7.010 4.432 2.381 1.172 4.480 52.331 Visualize Results
IIOF-NLDP [235] 7.796 3.806 40.287 6.651 4.175 2.300 0.731 3.328 53.670 Visualize Results
TVL1_LD_GF [236] 8.791 4.648 42.525 7.118 4.795 3.193 1.429 4.979 54.510 Visualize Results
RLOF_DENSE [237] 7.977 3.887 41.315 6.689 4.005 2.415 0.739 3.080 55.766 Visualize Results
TVL1_BWMFilter [238] 8.361 3.421 48.551 6.524 3.687 2.095 0.968 3.867 55.892 Visualize Results
ROF-NND [239] 8.061 3.944 41.603 6.365 4.145 2.756 0.717 3.301 56.051 Visualize Results
DF-Auto [240] 8.480 3.945 45.399 6.445 4.149 2.537 1.057 3.732 56.780 Visualize Results
DIS-Fast [241] 9.353 5.165 43.503 8.317 5.677 3.212 1.906 4.899 57.071 Visualize Results
PosetOptimization [242] 9.874 3.639 60.633 5.005 3.366 3.207 1.981 6.486 57.189 Visualize Results
Classic+NL [243] 7.961 3.770 42.079 6.191 3.911 2.509 0.573 2.694 57.374 Visualize Results
H+S_RVC [244] 10.495 6.400 43.824 8.992 7.084 4.920 2.504 7.319 57.754 Visualize Results
Horn+Schunck [245] 8.739 4.525 43.032 7.542 5.045 2.891 1.141 3.860 58.243 Visualize Results
H-1px [246] 10.148 4.454 56.545 6.832 4.306 3.637 2.173 6.606 58.262 Visualize Results
WRTflow [247] 8.236 4.048 42.320 6.413 4.250 2.774 0.598 3.106 58.550 Visualize Results
UnFlow [248] 9.379 5.365 42.105 7.853 5.151 3.886 1.312 5.116 59.713 Visualize Results
2bit-BM-tele [249] 9.274 4.219 50.491 6.233 4.119 3.323 1.390 4.564 59.833 Visualize Results
Classic++ [250] 8.721 4.259 45.047 6.983 4.494 2.753 0.902 3.295 60.645 Visualize Results
TV-L1 [251] 9.471 4.875 46.845 7.630 5.151 3.337 0.976 3.856 65.165 Visualize Results
BASELINE-Mean [252] 15.422 11.488 47.336 14.676 12.649 9.350 5.310 14.717 66.922 Visualize Results
Classic+NL-fast [253] 9.129 4.725 44.956 7.157 4.974 3.331 0.558 2.812 66.935 Visualize Results
S2D-Matching [254] 18.485 13.372 59.935 13.676 12.747 12.149 9.472 15.466 70.185 Visualize Results
OF_OCC_LD [255] 9.675 5.296 45.288 7.996 5.632 3.694 0.605 3.025 70.740 Visualize Results
Steered-L1 [256] 10.864 6.018 50.244 7.976 6.187 4.832 0.811 6.049 72.292 Visualize Results
Model_model [257] 14.669 10.081 51.960 11.437 10.100 9.394 3.502 12.036 76.191 Visualize Results
AnisoHuber.L1 [258] 12.642 7.983 50.472 10.457 8.675 6.320 0.753 9.976 77.835 Visualize Results
H+S_ROB [259] 13.278 8.654 50.879 11.490 9.560 6.700 1.552 10.011 79.168 Visualize Results
AtrousFlow [260] 14.200 9.584 51.758 11.964 10.338 7.926 1.702 12.440 80.185 Visualize Results
SimpleFlow [261] 12.617 7.848 51.435 10.693 8.422 6.170 0.711 8.411 81.786 Visualize Results
WKSparse [262] 15.765 11.414 51.045 13.469 11.864 10.609 2.756 15.781 81.907 Visualize Results
AVG_FLOW_ROB [263] 18.799 14.422 54.251 16.903 15.516 12.457 4.566 19.946 86.008 Visualize Results
BASELINE-zero [264] 18.926 14.396 55.633 17.050 15.613 12.172 4.049 20.873 87.342 Visualize Results
C-2px [265] 44.062 37.047 101.160 37.366 36.580 37.093 34.342 35.847 112.424 Visualize Results


Metrics


EPE Endpoint error over the complete frames
EPE matched Endpoint error over regions that remain visible in adjacent frames
EPE unmatched Endpoint error over regions that are visible only in one of two adjacent frames
d0-10 Endpoint error over regions closer than 10 pixels to the nearest occlusion boundary
d10-60 Endpoint error over regions between 10 and 60 pixels apart from the nearest occlusion boundary
d60-140 Endpoint error over regions between 60 and 140 pixels apart from the nearest occlusion boundary
s0-10 Endpoint error over regions with velocities lower than 10 pixels per frame
s10-40 Endpoint error over regions with velocities between 10 and 40 pixels per frame
s40+ Endpoint error over regions with velocities larger than 40 pixels per frame
All error images are normalized to be in the range between 0 and 1.

References
[1]
GroundTruth
[2]
RAFT
Zachary Teed and Jia Deng. RAFT: Recurrent All-Pairs Field Transforms for Optical Flow, ECCV 2020.
[3]
Deformable_RAFT
Anonymous. RAFT with deformable
[4]
RAFT-TF_RVC
Deqing Sun, Charles Herrmann, Varun Jampani, Mike Krainin, Forrester Cole, Austin Stone, Rico Jonschkowski, Ramin Zabih, William Freeman, and Ce Liu. A TensorFlow implementation of RAFT (Zachary Teed and Jia Deng. RAFT: Recurrent all-pairs field transforms for optical flow. ECCV 2020.) RVC 2020 submission.
[5]
DICL+
Anonymous. DICL+
[6]
ADLAB-PRFlow
Anonymous.
[7]
C-RAFT_RVC
RVC 2020 submission.
[8]
RAFT+LCV
Taihong Xiao, Jinwei Yuan, Deqing Sun, Qifei Wang, Xin-Yu Zhang, Kehan Xu, Ming-Hsuan Yang. Learnable Cost Volume using the Cayley Representation, ECCV 2020
[9]
MR-Flow
J. Wulff, L. Sevilla-Lara, M. J. Black: Optical Flow in Mostly Rigid Scenes. CVPR 2017.
[10]
ADW
Anonymous.
[11]
MaskFlownet
Shengyu Zhao, Yilun Sheng, Yue Dong, Eric I-Chao Chang, and Yan Xu. MaskFlownet: Asymmetric Feature Matching with Learnable Occlusion Mask, CVPR 2020 (Oral).
[12]
GCA-Net-ft+
Anonymous. finetune GCA-Net with a better data augmentation method
[13]
VCN
Gengshan Yang and Deva Ramanan. Volumetric Correspondence Networks for Optical Flow, NeurIPS 2019
[14]
H-v3
Anonymous.
[15]
ProFlow_ROB
D. Maurer, A. Bruhn: ProFlow: Learning to Predict Optical Flow. BMVC 2018. (ROB setting)
[16]
vcn+MSDRNet
Anonymous. None
[17]
MRFP
Anonymous.
[18]
VCN+LCV
Taihong Xiao, Jinwei Yuan, Deqing Sun, Qifei Wang, Xin-Yu Zhang, Kehan Xu, Ming-Hsuan Yang. Learnable Cost Volume using the Cayley Representation, ECCV 2020
[19]
metaFlow
Anonymous.
[20]
DICL-Flow
Displacement-invariant cost learning & Motion-aware projection layer
[21]
StarFlow
Pierre Godet, Alexandre Boulch, Aurélien Plyer, Guy Le Besnerais. STaRFlow: A SpatioTemporal Recurrent Cell for Lightweight Multi-Frame Optical Flow Estimation
[22]
PRAFlow_RVC
Anonymous.
[23]
ProFlow
D. Maurer, A. Bruhn: ProFlow: Learning to Predict Optical Flow. BMVC 2018.
[24]
FlowFields++
R. Schuster, C. Bailer, O. Wasenmüller, D. Stricker. FlowFields++: Accurate Optical Flow Correspondences Meet Robust Interpolation. ICIP 2018
[25]
SfM-PM
D. Maurer, N. Marniok, B. Goldluecke, A. Bruhn: Structure-from-Motion-Aware PatchMatch for Adaptive Optical Flow Estimation. ECCV 2018.
[26]
VCN_RVC
Gengshan Yang and Deva Ramanan. Volumetric Correspondence Networks for Optical Flow, NeurIPS 2019
[27]
GCA-Net
Anonymous.
[28]
MaskFlownet-S
Shengyu Zhao, Yilun Sheng, Yue Dong, Eric I-Chao Chang, and Yan Xu. MaskFlownet: Asymmetric Feature Matching with Learnable Occlusion Mask, CVPR 2020 (Oral).
[29]
PST
Anonymous. ACCV2018 submission #1195
[30]
MPIF
Anonymous. multi-level interpolation for optical flow estimation
[31]
LiteFlowNet3
Tak-Wai Hui and Chen Change Loy. LiteFlowNet3: Resolving Correspondence Ambiguity for More Accurate Optical Flow Estimation, ECCV 2020.
[32]
FlowFields+
C. Bailer, B. Taetz and D. Stricker. Flow Fields: Dense Correspondence Fields for Highly Accurate Large Displacement Optical Flow Estimation. T-PAMI.
[33]
LiteFlowNet3-S
Tak-Wai Hui and Chen Change Loy. LiteFlowNet3: Resolving Correspondence Ambiguity for More Accurate Optical Flow Estimation, ECCV 2020.
[34]
DIP-Flow
D. Maurer, M. Stoll, A. Bruhn: Directional Priors for Multi-Frame Optical Flow. BMVC 2018.
[35]
CoT-AMFlow
Anonymous.
[36]
LSM_FLOW_RVC
LSM: Learning Subspace Minimization for Low-level Vision for RVC2020
[37]
L0-norm-Flow2
OPL
[38]
PGM-C
Anonymous
[39]
CPM2
Coarse-to-fine PatchMatch for dense correspondence, Yunsong Li, Yinlin Hu, Rui Song, Peng Rao, Yangli Wang, submitted to T-CSVT
[40]
SegPM+Interpolation
SegPM+Interpolation
[41]
TV-Wavelet-Flow
SegPM+TV-Wavelet-Flow(Matlab code is available.)
[42]
PWC-Net+
Deqing Sun, Xiaodong Yang, Ming-Yu Liu, and Jan Kautz. Models Matter, So Does Training: An Empirical Study of CNNs for Optical Flow Estimation. TPAMI, to appear. arXiv link https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.05571
[43]
SegFlow33
Efficient Segmentation-Based PatchMatch for Large displacement Optical Flow Estimation. 2019 TCSVT. (d0=3, d1=3)(Matlab code is available.)
[44]
MFF
Zhile Ren, Orazio Gallo, Deqing Sun, Ming-Hsuan Yang, Erik B. Sudderth and Jan Kautz: A Fusion Approach for Multi-Frame Optical Flow Estimation. IEEE Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision (WACV 2019)
[45]
L0-normFlow
OPC
[46]
FrequencyFlow
FrequencyFlow+SegPM
[47]
SJTU_PAMI418
[48]
DiscreteFlow+OIR
D. Maurer, M. Stoll, A. Bruhn: Order-Adaptive and Illumination Aware Variational Optical Flow Refinement. BMVC 2017.
[49]
ARFlow-mv-ft
Liang Liu, Jiangning Zhang, Ruifei He, Yong Liu, Yabiao Wang, Ying Tai, et al. Learning by Analogy: Reliable Supervision from Transformations for Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation. CVPR 2020.
[50]
HMFlow
HMFlow: Hybrid Matching Optical Flow Network for Small and Fast-Moving Objects
[51]
MirrorFlow
Junhwa Hur and Stefan Roth. MirrorFlow: Exploiting Symmetries in Joint Optical Flow and Occlusion Estimation. ICCV 2017
[52]
FullFlow
Q. Chen, V. Koltun. Full Flow: Optical Flow Estimation By Global Optimization over Regular Grids. CVPR 2016.
[53]
FlowSAC_ff
Anonymous
[54]
STC-Flow
Anonymous.
[55]
ContinualFlow_ROB
Michal Neoral, Jan Šochman and Jiří Matas. Continual Occlusions and Optical Flow Estimation, ACCV 2018
[56]
DiscreteFlow
M. Menze, C. Heipke and A. Geiger. Discrete Optimization for Optical Flow. GCPR 2015
[57]
FullFlow+KF
W. Bao, Y. Xiao, L. Chen, and Z. Gao. Kalmanflow: Efficient Kalman Filtering for Video Optical Flow. ICIP 2018.
[58]
DCFlow
Jia Xu, René Ranftl, Vladlen Koltun. Accurate Optical Flow via Direct Cost Volume Processing. CVPR 2017.
[59]
RicFlow
Yinlin Hu, Yunsong Li, Rui Song. Robust Interpolation of Correspondences for Large Displacement Optical Flow. CVPR 2017.
[60]
SegFlow73
Efficient Segmentation-Based PatchMatch for Large displacement Optical Flow Estimation. 2019 TCSVT. (d0=7,d1=3)(Matlab code is available.)
[61]
FlowSAC_dcf
Anonymous.
[62]
FDFlowNet
Lingtong Kong and Jie Yang. FDFlowNet: Fast Optical Flow Estimation using a Deep Lightweight Network, ICIP 2020.
[63]
AugFNG_ROB
Anonymous.
[64]
OAS-Net
Anonymous.
[65]
CPM-Flow
Yinlin Hu, Rui Song, Yunsong Li. Efficient Coarse-to-Fine PatchMatch for Large Displacement Optical Flow. CVPR 2016.
[66]
S2F-IF
Yanchao Yang, Stefano Soatto. S2F: Slow-To-Fast Interpolator Flow. CVPR 2017.
[67]
LiteFlowNet2
Tak-Wai Hui, Xiaoou Tang, and Chen Change Loy. A Lightweight Optical Flow CNN - Revisiting Data Fidelity and Regularization, TPAMI 2020.
[68]
CPM_AUG
Anonymous. CVPR 18 submission #1939
[69]
SegFlow-CNN
SegFlow-CNN
[70]
DCFlow+KF
W. Bao, Y. Xiao, L. Chen, and Z. Gao. KalmanFlow 2.0: Efficient Video Optical Flow Estimation via Context-Aware Kalman Filtering. submitted to TIP.
[71]
CompactFlow
Anonymous. ICCV submission.
[72]
RichFlow-ft
Anonymous.
[73]
ProbFlowFields
Anne S. Wannenwetsch, Margret Keuper, Stefan Roth. ProbFlow: Joint Optical Flow and Uncertainty Estimation. ICCV 2017.
[74]
DistillFlow+ft
Anonymous. Supervised result.
[75]
SPM-BPv2
Y. Li, D. Min, M. S. Brown, M. N. Do, and J. Lu. SPM-BP: Sped-up PatchMatch Belief Propagation for Continuous MRFs. ICCV 2015. Improved version. Details coming soon.
[76]
DCFlow+KF2
W. Bao, Y. Xiao, L. Chen, and Z. Gao. KalmanFlow 2.0: Efficient Video Optical Flow Estimation via Context-Aware Kalman Filtering. submitted to TIP.
[77]
3Dflow
Improved
[78]
PatchBatch+Inter
T. Schuster, L. Wolf and D. Gadot: Optical Flow Requires Multiple Strategies (but only one network). CVPR 2017.
[79]
UnDAF-MaskFlownet
Anonymous.
[80]
IRR-PWC_RVC
RVC 2020 submission
[81]
ScopeFlow
Aviram Bar-Haim and Lior Wolf. ScopeFlow: Dynamic Scene Scoping for Optical Flow, CVPR 2020.
[82]
CompactFlow-woscv
Anonymous.
[83]
FastFlow
Anonymous.
[84]
DeepDiscreteFlow
F. Güney and A. Geiger. Deep Discrete Flow. Asian Conference on Computer Vision (ACCV) 2016.
[85]
FlowFieldsCNN
C. Bailer, K Varanasi and D. Stricker. CNN-based Patch Matching for Optical Flow with Thresholded Hinge Embedding Loss. CVPR 2017.
[86]
SENSE
Anonymous. TBA
[87]
FlowFields
C. Bailer, B. Taetz and D. Stricker. Flow Fields: Dense Correspondence Fields for Highly Accurate Large Displacement Optical Flow Estimation. ICCV 2015.
[88]
FastFlow2
Anonymous.
[89]
InterpoNet_df
S. Zweig, L Wolf. InterpoNet, A brain inspired neural network for optical flow dense interpolation. CVPR 2017.
[90]
Semantic_Lattice
Anne S. Wannenwetsch, Martin Kiefel, Peter V. Gehler, Stefan Roth. Learning Task-Specific Generalized Convolutions in the Permutohedral Lattice. GCPR 2019.
[91]
FF++_ROB
Accurate matching and robust interpolation. KITTI parameters as given by the paper. Edge detector trained on KITTI + Sintel + BSDS500.
[92]
InterpoNet_dm
S. Zweig, L Wolf. InterpoNet, A brain inspired neural network for optical flow dense interpolation. CVPR 2017.
[93]
PWC-Net+KF2
W. Bao, Y. Xiao, L. Chen, and Z. Gao. KalmanFlow 2.0: Efficient Video Optical Flow Estimation via Context-Aware Kalman Filtering. submitted to TIP.
[94]
PWC-Net_RVC
Deqing Sun, Xiaodong Yang, Ming-Yu Liu, and Jan Kautz. PWC-Net: CNNs for Optical Flow Using Pyramid, Warping, and Cost Volume, CVPR 2018. Renamed from PWC-Net_ROB to PWC-Net_RVC.
[95]
PPM
Parametric PatchMatch, Fangjun Kuang, master thesis, 2017
[96]
InterpoNet_ff
S. Zweig, L Wolf. InterpoNet, A brain inspired neural network for optical flow dense interpolation. CVPR 2017.
[97]
SBFlow
Fast Optical Flow Estimation Based on the Split Bregman Method. TCSVT 2016.(Matlab code is available.)
[98]
SegFlow113
Efficient Segmentation-Based PatchMatch for Large displacement Optical Flow Estimation. 2019 TCSVT. (d0=11,d1=3)(Matlab code is available.)
[99]
EPMNet
Anonymous. The high accuracy for both small and large motion estimation are mainly cause by two contributions: firstly, we present and implement an edge preserve patch match (EPM) layer that propagates self-similarity patterns in addition to offsets. The accuracy of optical flow prediction has greatly improved by this method. Secondly, we develop a course-to-fine network architecture to tackle large displacement estimation and introduce a residual flow method to solve small displacement estimation.
[100]
PWC-Net+KF
W. Bao, Y. Xiao, L. Chen, and Z. Gao. KalmanFlow 2.0: Efficient Video Optical Flow Estimation via Context-Aware Kalman Filtering. submitted to TIP.
[101]
FlowNet2
Anonymous. CVPR Submission #900
[102]
IRR-PWC
Junhwa Hur and Stefan Roth. Iterative Residual Refinement for Joint Optical Flow and Occlusion Estimation. CVPR 2019
[103]
InterpoNet_cpm
S. Zweig, L Wolf. InterpoNet, A brain inspired neural network for optical flow dense interpolation. CVPR 2017.
[104]
OccInpFlow
Occlusion is an inevitable and critical problem in unsupervised optical flow learning. Existing methods either treat occlusions equally as non-occluded regions or simply remove them to avoid incorrectness. However, the occlusion regions can provide effective information for optical flow learning. In this paper, we present OccInpFlow, an occlusion-inpainting framework to make full use of occlusion regions. Specifically, a new appearance-flow network is proposed to inpaint occluded flows based on the image content. Moreover, a boundary warp is proposed to deal with occlusions caused by displacement beyond image border. We conduct experiments on multiple leading flow benchmark data sets such as Flying Chairs, KITTI and MPI-Sintel, which demonstrate that the performance is significantly improved by our proposed occlusion handling framework.
[105]
FPCR-Net
Anonymous.
[106]
FPCR-Net2
Anonymous.
[107]
FastFlowNet-ft+
Anonymous.
[108]
TIMCflow
Fei Yang, Yongmei Cheng, Joost Van de Weijer, Mikhail G. Mozerov. 'Improved Discrete Optical Flow Estimation with Triple Image Matching Cost', IEEE Access
[109]
DPCTF
Anonymous. DPCTF
[110]
SelFlow
Pengpeng Liu, Michael R. Lyu, Irwin King, Jia Xu. SelFlow: Self-Supervised Learning of Optical Flow (CVPR 2019)
[111]
FlowNetC-MD
Anonymous.
[112]
EpicFlow
J. Revaud, P. Weinzaepfel, Z. Harchaoui and C. Schmid. EpicFlow: Edge-Preserving Interpolation of Correspondences for Optical Flow. CVPR 2015.
[113]
DistillFlow
Anonymous. Unsupervise result
[114]
Lavon
Anonymous.
[115]
GlobalPatchCollider
Shenlong Wang, Sean Fanello, Christoph Rhemann, Shahram Izadi and Pushmeet Kohli, The Global Patch Collider, CVPR, 2016
[116]
DefFlowP
Anonymous.
[117]
ERFlow
Anonymous.
[118]
IOFPL-CVr8-ft
Anonymous. IOFPL - Improving Optical Flow on a Pyramid Level (ECCV2020)
[119]
PRichFlow
Anonymous.
[120]
Devon
Anonymous. CVPR submission #1906
[121]
Flownet2-IAER
Anonymous. Flownet2 combining with illumination adjustment and edge refinement
[122]
Flownet2-IA
Anonymous. Flownet2 combining with illumination adjustment
[123]
OF-OEF
Anonymous. Optical flow estimation combining with objects edge features
[124]
FlowNet2-ft-sintel
Anonymous. CVPR Submission #900
[125]
PCF-F
Anonymous. PCF-F
[126]
SegFlow153
Efficient Segmentation-Based PatchMatch for Large displacement Optical Flow Estimation. 2019 TCSVT. (d0=15,d1=3)(Matlab code is available.)
[127]
PH-Flow
Jiaolong Yang and Hongdong Li. Dense, Accurate Optical Flow Estimation with Piecewise Parametric Model. CVPR 2015
[128]
IHBPFlow
Anonymous.
[129]
HSVFlow
Syed Tafseer Haider Shah, Xiang Xuezhi, Harbin Engineering University. Photometric Invariance of Optical Flow With Color Space Transformations
[130]
ARFlow-mv
Liang Liu, Jiangning Zhang, Ruifei He, Yong Liu, Yabiao Wang, Ying Tai, et al. Learning by Analogy: Reliable Supervision from Transformations for Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation. CVPR 2020.
[131]
PWC-Net
Deqing Sun, Xiaodong Yang, Ming-Yu Liu, and Jan Kautz. PWC-Net: CNNs for Optical Flow Using Pyramid, Warping, and Cost Volume, CVPR 2018.
[132]
StruPyNet-ft
Zefeng Sun, Hanli Wang, Yun Yi, and Qinyu Li, Structural Pyramid Network for Cascaded Optical Flow Estimation, The 26th International Conference on Multimedia Modeling (MMM’20) , Daejeon, Korea, Jan. 5-8, 2020.
[133]
tfFlowNet2
Anonymous.
[134]
StruPyNet
Zefeng Sun, Hanli Wang, Yun Yi, and Qinyu Li, Structural Pyramid Network for Cascaded Optical Flow Estimation, The 26th International Conference on Multimedia Modeling (MMM’20) , Daejeon, Korea, Jan. 5-8, 2020.
[135]
RichFlow-ft-fnl
Anonymous. final pass version
[136]
FALDOI
Roberto P.Palomares, Enric Meinhardt-Llopis, Coloma Ballester and Gloria Haro. FALDOI: A new minimization strategy for large displacement variational optical flow. To appear in JMIV
[137]
ARFlow
Liang Liu, Jiangning Zhang, Ruifei He, Yong Liu, Yabiao Wang, Ying Tai, et al. Learning by Analogy: Reliable Supervision from Transformations for Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation. CVPR 2020.
[138]
FGI
Y. Li, D. Min, M. N. Do, and J. Lu. Fast Guided Global Interpolation for Depth and Motion. ECCV 2016
[139]
F2PD_JJN
Anonymous. With Deformable Convolutional Networks
[140]
ER-FLOW2
Anonymous. Adjusted ERFlow
[141]
FAOP-Flow
Anonymous.
[142]
tfFlowNet2+GLR
Anonymous.
[143]
AggregFlow
D. Fortun, P. Bouthemy and C. Kervrann. Aggregation of local parametric candidates and exemplar-based occlusion handling for optical flow. CVIU 2016
[144]
FastFlowNet
Anonymous.
[145]
TF+OFM
R. Kennedy and C.J. Taylor. Optical Flow with Geometric Occlusion Estimation and Fusion of Multiple Frames. EMMCVPR 2015.
[146]
LiteFlowNet
Tak-Wai Hui, Xiaoou Tang, and Chen Change Loy. LiteFlowNet: A Lightweight Convolutional Neural Network for Optical Flow Estimation, CVPR 2018.
[147]
DeepFlow2
J. Revaud, P. Weinzaepfel, Z. Harchaoui and C. Schmid. DeepMatching: Hierarchical Deformable Dense Matching. Submitted to IJCV.
[148]
IOFPL-ft
Anonymous. IOFPL - Improving Optical Flow on a Pyramid Level (ECCV2020)
[149]
BOOM+PF.XY
Fast optical flow method (0.54s single core i7 @3.1GHz) that employs the permeability filter to interpolate NNF correspondences. The NNF is an improved version of CPM that uses a new binary descriptor termed BOOM instead of SiftFlow in order to efficiently compute matching costs. Publication: Towards Edge-Aware Spatio-Temporal Filtering in Real-Time. M. Schaffner, F. Scheidegger, L. Cavigelli, H. Kaeslin, L. Benini and A. Smolic. Accepted for publication in Trans. on Image Processing (TIP), 2017. DOI: 10.1109/TIP.2017.2757259
[150]
Deep+R
B. Drayer and T. Brox. Combinatorial Regularization of Descriptor Matching for Optical Flow Estimation. BMVC 2015
[151]
BOOM+PF.XYT
Fast optical flow method (0.59s single core i7 @3.1GHz) that employs the permeability filter to interpolate NNF correspondences. The NNF is an improved version of CPM that uses a new binary descriptor termed BOOM instead of SiftFlow in order to efficiently compute matching costs. Publication: Towards Edge-Aware Spatio-Temporal Filtering in Real-Time. M. Schaffner, F. Scheidegger, L. Cavigelli, H. Kaeslin, L. Benini and A. Smolic. Accepted for publication in Trans. on Image Processing (TIP), 2017. DOI: 10.1109/TIP.2017.2757259
[152]
F3-MPLF
Sathya N. Ravi, Yunyang Xiong, Lopamudra Mukherjee, Vikas Singh: Filter Flow made Practical: Massively Parallel and Lock-Free -- CVPR 2017
[153]
SegFlow193
Efficient Segmentation-Based PatchMatch for Large displacement Optical Flow Estimation. 2019 TCSVT. (d0=19,d1=3)(Matlab code is available.)
[154]
SparseFlowFused
Radu Timofte and Luc Van Gool. SparseFlow: Sparse Matching for Small to Large Displacement Optical Flow. WACV 2015
[155]
PPAC-HD3
Anne S. Wannenwetsch, Stefan Roth. Probabilistic Pixel-Adaptive Refinement Networks. CVPR 2020.
[156]
DeepFlow
P. Weinzaepfel, J. Revaud, Z. Harchaoui and C. Schmid. DeepFlow: Large displacement optical flow with deep matching. ICCV 2013.
[157]
HD3F+MSDRNet
Anonymous. HD3F+MSDRNet
[158]
SPM-BP
Y. Li, D. Min, M. S. Brown, M. N. Do, and J. Lu. SPM-BP: Sped-up PatchMatch Belief Propagation for Continuous MRFs. ICCV 2015
[159]
DDC_Net_stacked2
Anonymous. two times down-sampling of feature maps, 128 filters each layer, fine-tuned on sintel
[160]
HD3-Flow
Zhichao Yin, Trevor Darrell, Fisher Yu. Hierarchical Discrete Distribution Decomposition for Match Density Estimation (CVPR 2019)
[161]
DDC-Net
Anonymous.
[162]
AnyFlow
Anonymous. PAMI pending review
[163]
PCA-Layers
J. Wulff and M. J. Black: Efficient sparse-to-dense optical flow estimation using a learned basis and layers. CVPR 2015.
[164]
DMF_ROB
Baseline submission for ROB flow challenge: Deepflow with Deepmatching as prior
[165]
AutoScaler+
Anonymous. AutoScaler+
[166]
Deep-EIP
Anonymous. End-2-End learning for energy based inpainting of optical flow. ACCV submission 572
[167]
SVFilterOh
Mohamed A. Helala, Faisal Z. Qureshi, Fast Estimation of Large Displacement Optical Flow Using Dominant Motion Patterns & Sub-Volume PatchMatch Filtering, CRV 2017
[168]
PMF
J. Lu, Y. Li, H. Yang, D. Min, W. Eng, M. N. Do. PatchMatch Filter: Edge-Aware Filtering Meets Randomized Search for Visual Correspondence. TPAMI 2016
[169]
NNF-Local
Anonymous. Large Displacement Optical Flow from Nearest Neighbor Fields
[170]
UFlow
R. Jonschkowski, A. Stone, J. Barron, A. Gordon, K. Konolige, and A. Angelova. What Matters in Unsupervised Optical Flow. ECCV 2020. (Code is available)
[171]
ResPWCR_ROB
Anonymous.
[172]
PatchWMF-OF
Zhigang Tu, Coert Van Gemeren and Remco C. Veltkamp. Improved Color Patch Similarity Measure Based Weighted Median Filter. ACCV2014
[173]
Grts-Flow-V2
En Zhu, Yuanwei Li, Yanling Shi. Fast Optical Flow Estimation without Parallel Architectures. TCSVT
[174]
RGBFlow
Syed Tafseer Haider Shah, Xiang Xuezhi, Harbin Engineering University. Photometric Invariance of Optical Flow With Color Space Transformations
[175]
ICALD
M. Stoll, D. Maurer, S. Volz and A. Bruhn. Illumination-Aware Large Displacement Optical Flow. EMMCVPR 2017.
[176]
ZZZ
Anonymous.
[177]
WLIF-Flow
Z. Tu, R. Poppe, and R. C. Veltkamp. Weighted local intensity fusion method for variational optical flow estimation.Pattern Recognition,2015
[178]
ComponentFusion
Anonymous. Fast Optical Flow by Component Fusion. Submitted to ECCV 2014. Paper ID 941.
[179]
AGIF+OF
Anonymous. Signal Processing 2015
[180]
EPPM
L. Bao, Q. Yang, and H. Jin. Fast Edge-Preserving PatchMatch for Large Displacement Optical Flow. CVPR 2014.
[181]
M-1px
Anonymous.
[182]
MDP-Flow2
L. Xu, J. Jia, and Y. Matsushita. Motion detail preserving optical flow estimation. PAMI 34(9):1744-1757, 2012.
[183]
pwc_xx
[184]
RC-LSTM-4dir
Learning Contextual Dependencies for Optical Flow with Recurrent Neural Networks (ACCV 2016)
[185]
LocalLayering
D. Sun, C. Liu, and H. Pfister. Local Layering for Joint Motion Estimation and Occlusion Detection. CVPR 2014.
[186]
RC-LSTM-1dir
Learning Contextual Dependencies for Optical Flow with Recurrent Neural Networks (ACCV 2016)
[187]
COF_2019
H. Zimmer, A. Bruhn, J. Weickert, L. Valgaerts, A. Salgado, B. Rosenhahn, and H.-P. Seidel. Complementary optic flow. EMMCVPR 2009.
[188]
HCOF+multi
R. Kennedy and C. J. Taylor. Hierarchically-Constrained Optical Flow. CVPR 2015.
[189]
UnsupSimFlow
Unsupervised Learning of Optical Flow with Deep Feature Similarity, ECCV 2020
[190]
FlowNetC+ft+v
Anonymous. ICCV sumbmission 235
[191]
FlowNetS+ft+v
Anonymous. ICCV submission 235
[192]
DSPyNet
Zefeng Sun and Hanli Wang, Deeper Spatial Pyramid Network with Refined Up-Sampling for Optical Flow Estimation, 2018 Pacific Rim Conference on Multimedia (PCM'18), LNCS 11164, pp. 492-501, 2018.
[193]
DSPyNet+ft
Zefeng Sun and Hanli Wang, Deeper Spatial Pyramid Network with Refined Up-Sampling for Optical Flow Estimation, 2018 Pacific Rim Conference on Multimedia (PCM'18), LNCS 11164, pp. 492-501, 2018.
[194]
COF
H. Zimmer, A. Bruhn, J. Weickert, L. Valgaerts, A. Salgado, B. Rosenhahn, and H.-P. Seidel. Complementary optic flow. EMMCVPR 2009.
[195]
DDFlow
Pengpeng Liu, Irwin King, Michael R. Lyu, Jia Xu.  DDFlow: Learning Optical Flow with Unlabeled Data Distillation.  Thirty-Third AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence (AAAI), Jan 2019
[196]
OAR-Flow
D. Maurer, M. Stoll, A. Bruhn: Order-Adaptive Regularisation for Variational Optical Flow: Global, Local and in Between. SSVM 2017.
[197]
ContFusion
M. Stoll, D. Maurer, and A. Bruhn. Variational Large Displacement Optical Flow without Feature Matches. EMMCVPR 2017.
[198]
PatchBatch-CENT+SD
Anonymous.
[199]
PCA-Flow
J. Wulff and M. J. Black: Efficient sparse-to-dense optical flow estimation using a learned basis and layers. CVPR 2015.
[200]
SparseFlow
Radu Timofte and Luc Van Gool. SparseFlow: Sparse Matching for Small to Large Displacement Optical Flow. WACV 2015
[201]
Pwc_ps
Anonymous.
[202]
SPyNet
Ranjan, Anurag and Black, Michael J., Optical Flow Estimation using a Spatial Pyramid Network, Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 2017
[203]
SPyNet+ft
Ranjan, Anurag and Black, Michael J., Optical Flow Estimation using a Spatial Pyramid Network, Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 2017
[204]
SFL
Jingchun Cheng, Yi-Hsuan, Tsai, Shengjin Wang, Ming-Hsuan Yang. SegFlow: Joint Learning for Video Object Segmentation and Optical Flow. ICCV 2017
[205]
SAnet
Anonymous.
[206]
GeoFlow
Anonymous. Submission to Electrocnic Letters in 2018, we propose a simple but novel algorithm to achieve global belief propagation called geodesic-based Probability Propagation for optical flow estimation.
[207]
Back2FutureFlow_UFO
J. Janai, F. Güney, A. Ranjan, M. Black and A. Geiger. Unsupervised Learning of Multi-Frame Optical Flow with Occlusions. ECCV, 2018.
[208]
WOLF_ROB
[209]
Classic+NLP
D. Sun, S. Roth, and M. Black. A Quantitative Analysis of Current Practices in Optical Flow Estimation and The Principles behind Them. International Journal of Computer Vision (IJCV), 106(2):115-137, 2014.
[210]
SelFlow
Pengpeng Liu, Michael R. Lyu, Irwin King, Jia Xu. SelFlow: Self-Supervised Learning of Optical Flow (CVPR 2019)
[211]
EgFlow-cl
Anonymous. edge-guided, small parameter optical flow network based on CNN
[212]
FlowNetProbOut
Lightweight Probabilistic Deep Networks
[213]
FC-2Layers-FF
D. Sun, J. Wulff, E. Sudderth, H. Pfister, M.J. Black. A fully connected layered model of foreground and background flow. CVPR 2013
[214]
FlowNetADF
Lightweight Probabilistic Deep Networks
[215]
HAST
Yinlin Hu, Rui Song, Yunsong Li, Peng Rao, Yangli Wang. Highly Accurate Optical Flow Estimation on Superpixel Tree. Image and Vision Computing (IVC), 2016
[216]
IPOL_Brox
J. Sánchez, N. Monzón, and A. Salgado, Robust Optical Flow Estimation, Image Processing On Line (IPOL), 3 (2013), pp. 252–270.
[217]
FSU-Net
Anonymous.
[218]
EPIflow
Deep Epipolar Flow
[219]
DF-Beta
Nelson Monzón, Agustín Salgado and Javier Sánchez. Regularization Strategies for Discontinuity-Preserving Optical Flow Methods. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, Vol 25(4), pp. 1580 - 1591, 2016
[220]
CPNFlow
Conditional Prior Networks for Optical Flow, Yanchao Yang, Stefano Soatto; The European Conference on Computer Vision (ECCV), 2018, pp. 271-287
[221]
DF
Nelson Monzón, Agustín Salgado and Javier Sánchez. Regularization Strategies for Discontinuity-Preserving Optical Flow Methods. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, Vol 25(4), pp. 1580 - 1591, 2016
[222]
CNet
Anonymous.
[223]
Channel-Flow
L. Sevilla-Lara, D. Sun, E. Learned-Miller, and M. Black. Optical Flow Estimation with Channel Constancy. ECCV, pages 423-438, 2014.
[224]
JOF
Anonymous.
[225]
OatNet01
Anonymous.
[226]
NLTGV-SC
R. Ranftl, K. Bredies, T. Pock. Non-Local Total Generalized Variation for Optical Flow Estimation, ECCV 2014
[227]
Data-Flow
Anonymous. CSAD data cost + second order smoothness
[228]
MLDP-OF
M. Mohamed, H. Rashwan, B. Mertsching, M. Garcia, and D. Puig. Illumination-robust optical flow approach using local directional pattern. Accepted in IEEE TCSVT 2014.
[229]
TV-L1+EM
V. Lazcano. EXHAUSTIVE MATCHING EMPIRICAL STUDY FOR IMPROVING THE MOTION FIELD ESTIMATION
[230]
LDOF
T. Brox, J. Malik. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 33(3): 500-513, 2011.
[231]
FlowNetC+OFR
Anonymous.
[232]
DictFlowS
Anonymous.
[233]
TVL1_ROB
Baseline submission for the robust vision flow challenge: TV-L1 Optical Flow Estimation
[234]
TVL1_RVC
RVC 2020 baseline submission, based on: J. Sanchez, E. Meinhardt-Llopis, and G. Facciolo
[235]
IIOF-NLDP
Dinh-Hoan Trinh, Walter Blondel, and Christian Daul. A General Form of Illumination-Invariant Descriptors in Variational Optical Flow Estimation. ICIP 2017.
[236]
TVL1_LD_GF
V. Lazcano. TVL1 to handle large displacements using gradient patches. Parameter where optimized using PSO.
[237]
RLOF_DENSE
Jonas Geistert, Tobias Senst and Thomas Sikora, Robust Local Optical Flow: Dense Motion Vector Field Interpolation, PCS 2016
[238]
TVL1_BWMFilter
Balanced Weighted Median Filter and Bilateral Filter.
[239]
ROF-NND
Sharib Ali, Christian Daul, Ernest Galbrun, Walter Blondel, Illumination invariant optical flow using neighborhood descriptors, Computer Vision and Image Understanding, Available online 17 December 2015, ISSN 1077-3142.
[240]
DF-Auto
Nelson Monzón, Agustín Salgado and Javier Sánchez. Regularization Strategies for Discontinuity-Preserving Optical Flow Methods. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, Vol 25(4), pp. 1580 - 1591, 2016
[241]
DIS-Fast
T. Kroeger, R. Timofte, D. Dai, L. Van Gool, Fast Optical Flow using Dense Inverse Search. ECCV 2016. Run-time: 0.023 s (20ms preprocessing, 3ms flow computation). Using operating point 2 of the paper.
[242]
PosetOptimization
Anonymous.
[243]
Classic+NL
D. Sun, S. Roth, and M. Black. Secrets of optical flow estimation and their principles. CVPR, pages 2432-2439, 2010.
[244]
H+S_RVC
RVC 2020 baseline submission, based on: E. Meinhardt-Llopis, J. Sanchez, and D. Kondermann.
[245]
Horn+Schunck
A modern Matlab implementation of the Horn & Schunck method by Deqing Sun.
[246]
H-1px
Anonymous.
[247]
WRTflow
We proposed a weighted regularization transform to reduce the influence of illumination variations of optical flow estimation. We submit it to TCSVT.
[248]
UnFlow
Anonymous.
[249]
2bit-BM-tele
Rui Xu & David Taubman, Robust Dense Block-Based Motion Estimation Using a Two-Bit Transform on a Laplacian Pyramid, ICIP 2013 +telescopic search
[250]
Classic++
D. Sun, S. Roth, and M. Black. Secrets of optical flow estimation and their principles. CVPR, pages 2432-2439, 2010.
[251]
TV-L1
Anonymous. It is a well-known model that uses TV-L1 (coupled) as the regularization term and an L1 data term.
[252]
BASELINE-Mean
[253]
Classic+NL-fast
D. Sun, S. Roth, and M. Black. Secrets of optical flow estimation and their principles. CVPR, pages 2432-2439, 2010.
[254]
S2D-Matching
M. Leordeanu, A. Zanfir, C. Sminchisescu. Locally Affine Sparse-to-Dense Matching for Motion and Occlusion estimation. ICCV 2013
[255]
OF_OCC_LD
V. Lazcano, L. Garrido, C. Ballester. Jointly Optical flow and Occlusion Estimation for images with Large Displacements.
[256]
Steered-L1
Anonymous.
[257]
Model_model
Anonymous. this is a model
[258]
AnisoHuber.L1
M. Werlberger, W. Trobin, T. Pock, A. Wedel, D. Cremers, and H. Bischof. Anisotropic Huber-L1 optical flow. BMVC 2009.
[259]
H+S_ROB
Baseline submission for the ROB flow challenge: Horn-Schunck Optical Flow with a Multi-Scale Strategy
[260]
AtrousFlow
Anonymous. Real-time dense optical flow using CUDA
[261]
SimpleFlow
M. W. Tao, J. Bai, P. Kohli, and S. Paris. "SimpleFlow: A Non-iterative, Sublinear Optical Flow Algorithm". Computer Graphics Forum (Eurographics 2012), 2012. (OpenCV 2.4.5 Implementation, parameters provided by OpenCV sample)
[262]
WKSparse
[263]
AVG_FLOW_ROB
Average flow field of ROB2018 training set. No image information used!
[264]
BASELINE-zero
[265]
C-2px
Anonymous.